.png)
A Night of Near-Misses and Last-Gasp Drama: Newcastle's Frustrating Stalemate with Spurs
- NUFC TALK TV
- Dec 3, 2025
- 6 min read
Man, if there's one thing that sums up Newcastle United's season so far, it's Tuesday night's 2-2 draw against Tottenham at St James' Park. You could feel the electricity in the air before kickoff, 52,000 Geordies roaring their lungs out, desperate for a win to haul Eddie Howe's side out of the mid-table muck.
But what unfolded was a classic case of "so close, yet so far," a match that had everything: blistering attacks, dodgy VAR calls, and a finish that left everyone scratching their heads. Newcastle bossed it for chunks of the game, only to let victory slip away twice like sand through their fingers.
Let's break it down, shall we? Because this one deserves more than a quick skim, it's got layers, and not all of 'em are pretty.
LISTEN TO NUFC Talk Radio LIVE
The Build-Up: High Hopes, Creaky Foundations
Heading into this one, Newcastle were sitting 13th with 19 points from 14 games, a far cry from the Champions League chasers of last season. Injuries have been brutal, Alexander Isak's absence up top has left a gaping hole, and the fixture list hasn't helped.
Spurs, meanwhile, were in freefall under Thomas Frank, winless in five league games and staring down the barrel of a fourth straight defeat across all comps. But away days at St James' have a habit of waking up the sleeping giants, and Tottenham arrived with a point to prove after that humiliating home loss to Chelsea.
Eddie Howe went with a familiar 4-3-3: Aaron Ramsdale in goal, a back four of Valentino Livramento, Malick Thiaw, Dan Burn, and Lewis Hall, midfield trio of Lewis Miley, Sandro Tonali, and Joelinton, and up front Jacob Murphy, Nick Woltemade, and Harvey Barnes. Bruno Guimarães started on the bench, more on that later, while Spurs lined up in a cautious 4-2-3-1 with Guglielmo Vicario behind Pedro Porro, Cristian Romero, Kevin Danso, and Destiny Udogie; Rodrigo Bentancur and Pape Matar Sarr anchoring midfield; Mohammed Kudus, Lucas Bergvall, and Brennan Johnson behind Randal Kolo Muani.
From the off, it was clear Newcastle wanted to press high and hard, channeling that "heavy metal" football Howe loves. The crowd was up for it, but Spurs, sensing the trap, opted for direct balls to counter the chaos. It was cagey early doors, neither side landing a clean punch, but you could tell the Magpies had the edge in intensity.
The Action: A Tale of Two Halves, With a Chaotic Finish
First half? A bit of a slog, if I'm honest. Newcastle dominated possession, around 58% by the break, and peppered the Spurs box with crosses, but Vicario was on song, punching away corners like he was swatting flies.
Joelinton rattled the post in the 35th minute with a low drive that had the Gallowgate End on its feet, pure "what if" stuff. Spurs weren't exactly dormant; Lucas Bergvall nearly nicked one with a cheeky backheel that looped just over. But for all Newcastle's huffing and puffing, it stayed 0-0 at the interval. You got the sense the dam was about to break.
Enter the second half, and boy, did it. Howe hooked Tonali for Bruno Guimarães at the break, a move that screamed "time to unlock this lot." And unlock they did. Barely five minutes in, Barnes stung Vicario's palms, and Woltemade's header was clawed off the line by Danso.
The pressure built like a storm, and in the 71st minute, it burst. Gordon, who'd come on for Barnes, tore down the left, centered to Woltemade for a clever flick-on, and there was Guimarães, ghosting in late to curl a beauty into the bottom corner. 1-0! St James' erupted, Bruno's 12th goal involvement in his last 20 home games, and a reminder of why he's the heartbeat of this team.
But football's a cruel mistress, innit? Spurs, who'd been hanging on by their fingernails, hit back seven minutes later. Kudus whipped in a cross from the right, and Romero, Spurs' captain, fresh off a suspension, dived to head it home. 1-1. Cue pandemonium.
What are Toon fans saying? Watch below!
Newcastle looked shell-shocked, their high press fizzling as fatigue crept in. That heavy metal style? It's exhilarating, but man, it's draining. Howe's lads started looking leggy, mentally more than anything.
The finale was pure madness. From a corner, Bentancur got tangled with Burn in the box. VAR had a squint, and after an eternity, ref Tom Bramall pointed to the spot. Soft as butter, some said, but Gordon stepped up cool as you like and smashed it low past Vicario. 2-1, 86th minute. Victory in sight! The place was bouncing; you could almost taste three points that'd catapult Newcastle into the top half.
Except... Romero. Again. In the 90+5th, another corner caused havoc in the six-yard box. Bodies everywhere, and the Argentine defender, Spurs' only real threat all night, scuffed an overhead kick that somehow bobbled through the crowd and past a flailing Ramsdale. 2-2. St James' fell silent, then erupted in frustration. Post-whistle, it nearly kicked off, Romero and Guimarães squaring up, Joelinton wading in, Dan Burn stirring the pot. Classic Premier League theater, but for Newcastle fans, it stung like a betrayal.
Key Stats: Dominance Without the Punch
Let's get nerdy for a sec, because the numbers tell a story of "what might have been."
Newcastle outshot Spurs 18-7, with 6 on target to Tottenham's measly 2, both from Romero, naturally.
Expected goals? Magpies at 1.96, Spurs scraping a 0.79, basically Newcastle created the chances of a comfy win but couldn't bury them.
Possession tilted 55-45 to the hosts, corners 8-4.
But here's the kicker: Newcastle's defense, usually a fortress at home, leaked two soft ones from set pieces. And that xG gap? It's the third time this season the Magpies have posted over 1.5 xG in a draw or loss. Ouch.
Stat Category | Newcastle | Tottenham |
Possession | 55% | 45% |
Shots (on target) | 18 (6) | 7 (2) |
Expected Goals | 1.96 | 0.79 |
Corners | 8 | 4 |
Fouls | 12 | 14 |
Big Chances | 4 | 1 |
Spurs, for their part, were clinical when it counted. Romero's brace from two efforts is the stuff of nightmares for opposition keepers. But let's not kid ourselves, this was a smash-and-grab, the kind that leaves you fuming about fine margins.
Best Takeaways: Heroes Emerge, But Cracks Show
Bruno Guimarães: Subbed on and bossed it, that goal was a chef's kiss, and his leadership post-match, even in the scuffle, underlined why he's indispensable.
Harvey Barnes and Lewis Hall: Terrorized the left flank, Barnes' shot early in the second half was a warning sign Spurs ignored.
Jacob Murphy: Underrated work rate, even if his end product was off.
For Spurs, Romero was the undisputed man of the match. Two goals, both clutch, including that bicycle kick that's already looping on every highlight reel. Mohammed Kudus deserves a nod too, his cross for the first equalizer was pinpoint.
But the real takeaway? Newcastle's inability to kill games. They've dropped 11 points from winning positions this season, tied for the league's worst with Brentford. That high-pressing style is gold when it clicks, but against organized sides like Spurs, it leaves you exposed late on.
Howe's post-match grimace said it all: "We had enough to win, but we didn't see it out." Spot on, Eddie. And that VAR pen? Controversial as hell, Jamie Redknapp called it baffling on Sky, pointing to inconsistency. Refs, always the scapegoat, but here it felt like salt in the wound.
The Poor Stats: Where It All Went Wrong
Defensively, this was a horror show from set pieces, both Spurs goals came from corners, exposing Ramsdale's positioning and the backline's marking. Dan Burn gets pelters for that wrestle with Bentancur, but the whole unit looked ragged after 70 minutes.
Fatigue's no excuse, but with a packed schedule, Howe's rotation, or lack thereof, is biting.
Up top, without Isak, the finishing was profligate. Woltemade and Barnes created chances but lacked that killer edge. Murphy's 1.4 shots on target per game average held up, but conversion? Zilch.
Tonali's benching early highlighted midfield fragility without Bruno from the off. Overall, Newcastle's home form is solid, unbeaten in 10 midweek evening games since 2021, but against top-six sides? They've won the last three PL meetings with Spurs 12-2 aggregate, yet couldn't make it four.
Frustration indeed, talent's there, execution's not.
Wrapping It Up: A Point That Feels Like Two Lost
In the end, this draw keeps Newcastle treading water, still 13th, still eyeing Europe but miles from the summit. For Spurs, it's a lifeline, easing the heat on Frank and snapping that skid.
For Geordies, it was a thriller that exposed both teams' soft underbellies. Newcastle need to sharpen that killer instinct, plug the set-piece sieve, and pray Isak's back soon. Otherwise, this season's shaping up like last year's sequel, promising start, frustrating fade.
What a sport, eh? Roll on the next one, let's hope it's not another heartbreaker. Howay the Lads, but maybe with a bit more bite next time.
Comments